|
|
Buying Guide
We keep telling those who approach us for laptop
buying suggestions the same thing : enter the market only if
armed with atleast one of two things - a budget or a spec list.
A budget is the max that the buyer is willing to spend on the laptop
and a spec list is the list of components that the laptop should
contain.
Without either, a buyer is bound to get lost in the maze of options and
end up with a device that is not optimal. Since it is easy to check
one's wallet, fixing a budget is a definite prerequisite to entering
the market for those who are not tech savvy to decide on the spec list.
The answer to the question "What do I want to do with the laptop?"
needs to be boiled down to either of the aforementioned criteria.
If you have finalised a budget, check the local and online stores for
the laptops that squeeze into the constraint. Then go online and
compare the configurations of the laptops offered to find which one is
the beefiest.
If it is a specification list that you have settled on, first go online
and find the laptop that packs in all that you need. Then check prices
from the local /online dealers for those shortlisted laptops.
Since the dealer has little or no impact on the quality of the laptop
and its service, it doesn't matter much from where the laptop is
purchased. So go to the cheapest seller. But, it is highly recommended
to get a first hand experience of the laptop before putting down the
money and here the local dealer scores over online shops.
Of course one critical question needs to be considered before you even
begin.
Is a Laptop what I need?
Price
wise, Repairability wise, Simplicity wise, Expandability wise and
ergonomically the desktop scores over a laptop. The laptop gains an
upperhand with respect to portability, power economy, space economy,
battery backup, and looks.
And, now, with the advent of economically priced Tablets offering most
of these features, laptops are being squeezed into a narrowing niche
which will soon be non existent.
We strongly recommend a laptop only for those who need to carry the
machine around, and also need some features that Tablets are, so far,
unable to provide for cheap
- like, a 14 inch ( or larger) screen, and allowing USB devices to be
plugged in. For other reasons, a desktop or Tablet is easily a much
better alternative. Consider the following :
1. At the lower end (pricewise), for the price of the cheapest laptop a
desktop with a more powerful configuration, a larger screen and
ergonomically designed keyboard and mouse can be had. The large screen
makes a huge difference, since with multitasking becoming the norm, a
15.6" screen seems microscopic compared to a 22" screen (at the same
price, 8000 approx). Additionally, because components are standardised,
it is easier and cheaper to upgrade and repair desktops.
2. At the higher end, Tablets come with most of the features necessary
to do the important jobs. They offer significantly better battery life
and lower weight which are quite important for people on the move. The
minor drawbacks of the Tablet, vis a vis the laptop, namely smaller
screen, limited expansion options, and no optical drive, should get
resolved in the near future if the past is anything to go by. Ofcourse,
Tablets that are cheaper than Laptops are also available. The Akash, though cheap at Rs.4000, may not have
enough juice for most of today's tasks, but that is just a sign of
things to come.
Atleast between a Desktop and a Laptop, energy
conservation is a strong reason to get a laptop, since the components
used are always less power consuming than their desktop counterparts.
If the budget is not a constraint, getting a laptop just to be GREEN is
a commendable decision. This is more the case as it is becoming a
fashion to set one's computer to download round the clock over an
unlimited broadband connection. In such situations, a laptop which
consumes close to 50% of the desktop's energy intake will make a
difference. (Check these links : http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/000562.html
http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/000353.html
for a rough idea.) For such situations, we also recommend picking up
dirt cheap second hand laptops that have defective parts including
display, keyboard, speakers etc since they do the job just fine.
Once the existential question has been considered, next step would be
evaluating important laptop features. It is easy to be swayed by the
glossy adwork and jargon blitzkrieg utilised by some manufacturers to
sell their wares. Most times a laptop buyer is
overwhelmed by all this and ignores the viewing a laptop holistically.
Here are a few points that merit attention :
a. More is not always better
More GHz, More Cores, More GB, More Inches etc are
enticing. But there are some caveats :
i. Cores and GHz : If boasting rights do
not matter, neither do GHz and the number of cores, in most cases. We
find it amusing when people who have no interest in playing games come
over asking for the laptop with the fastest multi cored CPU. When we
explain that given their workload (the usual : browsing, chatting,
documents), there would be no difference experienced between an entry
level laptop with a much slower and single cored CPU, they are
downright shocked. A fast, multicored CPU will make a difference only
if the application to be used is CPU intensive, and compatible with
multi core processing. Most games, though CPU intensive are not
multicore compatible. And most delays that are caused while using
video/graphics editing software are a result of less RAM than less GHz.
ii. Memory sizes : More RAM need not be
effectual beyond a certain threshold. 2 GB RAM seems to be the norm,
but the opportunity for all that RAM to be ever utilised will be rare,
if all that the user will do is watch movies, browse the net or type a
few memos. With 2 GB of RAM, a user should be playing 3D games or do a
lot of video/photo editing to do justice to the device. So a system
with 1 GB of RAM need not be crippled in the memory department with
regard to a system with 2 GB of RAM.
iii. Screen Size/Resolution :
A larger screen that does not support higher resolutions need not be a
boon : a 14.1" screen and a 15.6" screen supporting 1280 X 800 wide
screen resolution show the same amount of data (though the larger
screen will show screen elements a bit bigger.). But the larger screen
will weigh more and drain the battery faster.
LCDs unlike CRTs do not perform well at all resolutions. The quoted
resolution is the LCD's"native" resolution and the images will appear a
bit blurred if the screen is not used at this resolution. This would be
of interest to those who intend to use the laptop for gaming. Unless
the hardware can handle the native resolution, the graphics will appear
air brushed.
iv. Portability v/s Features : The
bigger
the feature list the heavier the laptop. Laptop weight is usually
overlooked when the other features are glossed over. As a rule of
thumb, if you are looking for a laptop that has "everything", don't
expect it to be lightweight as well.
The gist is that a balance must be sought. Getting
the fastest CPU for the buck need not create the biggest bang.
b. The Chipset
This is almost never a part of the discussion.
Everyone wants to know
the CPU and the RAM but not what brings them together as a team. In our
view, a chipset plays a greater role than the CPU is defining the usage
experience. While many aspects of the laptop are defined by the
chipset, like power management, connectivity options etc , it is the
graphics part that requires greater consideration. A weak graphics
component can result in significant deterioration in multimedia
performance. Opting for a laptop that has better onboard graphics is
recommended, even if the CPU is weaker, since the overall experience
will be better (this does not apply to those laptops that have a
dedicated graphics card). In this regard, it is better to opt for
chipsets made by Intel, AMD/ATI or nVidia over those made by SiS and
Via. It is recommended to check online sources about overheating issues
with chipsets - nVidia chipsets seem most prone to failures in this
regard.
c. Connectivity/Expandability options
Unlike a desktop where it is easy to expand the
capablities of a system
by adding expansion cards, a Laptop offers severely limited upgrade
paths. So it is best to get a laptop offering most connectivity
options. USB ports are crucial, and atleast 3 ports are highly
recommended. Memory card readers are gaining importance, since digital
cameras are becoming popular (though it is easy to get USB based memory
card readers). Bluetooth also would be an advantage since this would go
well with similarly capable mobile phones (here too, USB based
solutions are available). Default connectivity options like Wireless
LAN, Wired LAN and dial up modem are almost standard, with broadband
getting popular, the dial up modem may be on its way out, so those
still using this service should select appropriately. VGA out ports
that allow connecting to an external monitor is a must, and is
available in most laptops, but not so in the case with HDMI port which
can be used to plug the laptop to a HD TV.
d. Laptop design
The laptop's layout with regard to the ports,
switches, locks etc should not be ignored.
i. While 3 USB ports are desirable,
the location of the ports is also an important issue. For right
handers, it is more convenient to have majority of the ports on the
right side.
ii. Having audion
ports on either side in the front can be undesirable since the hand
could press down on the connected plugs then typing. Centrally placed
ports are better.
iii. The area
below
the keypad where the wrist rests can get hot if the hard disk is
located under that area. This will make typing over long periods a
painful affair.
iv. Backlit keypad
goes a long way in making typing in the dark a pleasant affair.
v. Quick access
buttons to control different subsystems are better, only if they will
be used. Touch sensitive buttons are a headache since they tend to get
activated at the slightest touch, in some cases this usually powers up
the system as well.
vi. Having hard
locks with latches that keep the lid closed is better than spring shut
lids since the latter will allow things to make their way in,
potentially damaging the screen.
vii.15.6 inch
screens are quite popular, unfortunately most of these laptops also
have a keypad with a discrete numeric
section. Such keypads are a
pain,
since typing requires placing the wrists towards one side of the
laptop, and not the center. While this position is not a major issue
when the laptop is placed on a table, the same cannot be said when
using the laptop on one's lap. Ergonomically, it is better to opt for
laptops that do not have a distinct numeric section.
Laptops that have two locks to retain the battery are better if the
laptop will go through lot of vibration.
e. Warranty/Service Conditions
Warranty
durations are easy to understand, the more the better. Onsite and
offsite conditions need to be clarified. Onsite warranty is always
better, though unlike a desktop, carrying the laptop to some place is
not a big hassle. Still, especially, if there are no authorised service
centers in town, onsite is preferable but many laptops do come with a
"within city limits" fine print. Same business day service would be
useful for those who rely extensively on their laptops. If an upgrade
is offered to extend warranty or increase priority of service, the
former is better since, laptops tend to break down more with the
passage of time, due to the mobility and compactness factors.
Additionally, laptop service is an expensive and time consuming affair,
with the cheapest replaceable component costing upwards of Rs. 1000.
Recommended reading
Notebookcheck.net's buying tips
A good article at Notebookreview
PCMag's tips on buying a business laptop.
Notebookreview.com's Netbook buying tips
Notebookcheck.net's page on mobile CPUs
If you are planning to get a Used Laptop also read the Used Laptop Buying Guide for pointers.
|